references:related_fields:interoception-and-neds

Interoception and somatic experience in NEDS

Interoception concerns sensing signals from within the body. It offers a useful research connection for NEDS because the framework includes bodily experience in its account of a recurring psychological configuration. The important question is which aspect of bodily experience is being described or measured: a sensation, attention to it, an interpretation, physiological activity, or the ability to detect an internal signal accurately.

Keeping those distinctions clear allows bodily experience to contribute information without assigning it a predetermined psychological meaning. This page compares research constructs and measures with the NEDS proposal of a somatic signature.

Somatic experience is broader than one measure

The 2026 NEDS appraisal describes a somatic signature as a recurring pattern involving sensations, posture, breathing, or physiological reactivity associated with an activation. That includes more than interoception alone. A person's felt breathing, an observer's description of posture, and a recorded physiological signal are different sources of information. Combining them requires a stated rationale rather than treating them as interchangeable. Kržić, 2026, section 7

The proposed signature also has a narrower purpose than general body awareness: it concerns a recurring configuration linked to a particular activation. A measure of how often someone notices bodily sensations cannot establish that configuration on its own.

Three distinctions from interoception research

Garfinkel and colleagues distinguished three dimensions in a study of 80 participants:

Dimension in that study Meaning Question for NEDS research
Interoceptive accuracy Performance on a task assessing detection of bodily signals Does a claim concern detection ability, or something else?
Interoceptive sensibility Self-reported experience or beliefs about bodily sensitivity Is the finding about what a person reports noticing?
Interoceptive awareness Correspondence between task accuracy and confidence Does confidence track correct judgments?

The dimensions were distinguishable; confidence and self-report could not simply substitute for task performance. The authors used “awareness” in a specific metacognitive sense, so readers should check how each paper defines the term. Garfinkel et al., 2015

Applied to NEDS, a detailed description of sensations is evidence about reported experience. It is not automatically evidence of accurate physiological detection, a distinctive neuro-entity, or an improvement in either. This distinction preserves the value of the account while locating the claim at the appropriate level.

What the MAIA adds

The Multidimensional Assessment of Interoceptive Awareness, or MAIA, was developed to distinguish aspects of bodily awareness that a single sensitivity score can obscure. Its original 32-item version contained eight scales, including Noticing, Not-Worrying, Attention Regulation, Self-Regulation, and Trusting. Development involved a field-test sample of 325 people with experience of mind–body practices. Mehling et al., 2012

For NEDS research, the useful distinction is between noticing a sensation and how someone relates to it. A person might report sensations more often while also becoming more worried about them. Alternatively, their reports of frequency might remain similar while their ability to direct attention or their sense of bodily trust changes. These are different possible outcomes, not successive levels on one ladder.

The MAIA provides self-report dimensions, not a physiological assay or a NEDS-specific validation instrument. Its title also uses “awareness” more broadly than Garfinkel's task-based metacognitive definition. A research report should name the scale and dimension rather than claiming simply that “interoception improved.”

Why the measurement task matters

Even apparently objective tasks need scrutiny. Ring and colleagues compared immediate and delayed heartbeat feedback. Both improved subsequent heartbeat-counting performance, although only immediate feedback marked individual contractions. This supported a role for updated knowledge about heart rate rather than improved detection of heartbeat sensations. Ring et al., 2015

The implication for NEDS is methodological: a numerical score does not establish the mechanism its label suggests. If a project studies bodily detection, it must justify the task. If it studies subjective intensity, a report may be appropriate, but the result should remain a subjective-intensity result. Likewise, physiological recording measures the selected physiological variable; it does not identify the psychological meaning of an episode without additional evidence.

Research questions for a somatic signature

The appraisal proposes testing whether signatures are reproducible and add information beyond simpler descriptions. A focused research design could ask:

  • Recurrence: Does a prespecified pattern recur within the same person across comparable episodes? Record exceptions as well as matches.
  • Specificity: Does it distinguish the proposed activation from other situations? A pattern appearing across many unrelated circumstances may be too nonspecific for the intended interpretation.
  • Independent identification: Can observers using explicit criteria recognize the pattern without knowing the favored formulation or later outcome?
  • Added value: Does including the bodily pattern improve prediction beyond the person's report of distress, prior behavior, and relevant context?
  • Change: Which component changes first, and does that change predict later functioning? A quieter bodily response and a more flexible behavioral response should not be assumed to be the same outcome.

These questions describe a possible investigation, not an established screening instrument. They also allow a useful negative result: a repeatable bodily pattern may be real but add little to prediction, or may support a simpler explanation than a neuro-entity formulation.

Using the connection carefully

Interoception research gives NEDS better distinctions and candidate measures. The NEDS-specific contribution would have to lie in demonstrating that its proposed organization of bodily, emotional, cognitive, and behavioral information improves understanding or prediction. A shared interest in the body does not supply that result.

For an introductory explanation of the concept itself, see What a bodily signal can tell us in NEDS. The reference question is more specific: what exactly was measured, what changed, and which interpretation survives comparison with alternatives?

Sources

  • Garfinkel, S. N., Seth, A. K., Barrett, A. B., Suzuki, K., and Critchley, H. D. (2015). Knowing your own heart: distinguishing interoceptive accuracy from interoceptive awareness. Biological Psychology, 104, 65–74. DOI; PubMed.
  • Mehling, W. E., et al. (2012). The Multidimensional Assessment of Interoceptive Awareness (MAIA). PLOS ONE, 7, e48230. Full text.
  • Ring, C., Brener, J., Knapp, K., and Mailloux, J. (2015). Effects of heartbeat feedback on beliefs about heart rate and heartbeat counting: a cautionary tale about interoceptive awareness. Biological Psychology, 104, 193–198. DOI; PubMed.
  • Kržić, M. (2026). From Structural Limits to a Testable Response. Version 1.0, especially sections 5, 7–7.1, and 12–13. Zenodo. First-party conceptual appraisal and research program.

Related Fields

references/related_fields/interoception-and-neds.txt · Last modified: by mkrzic