This is an old revision of the document!
Table of Contents
When the reward changes only on paper
Before calling a response habitual, check what its outcome still means to the person performing it.
By Julian Rowe
Published: 12 November 2026
Consider a hypothetical example. Daniel helps organize a small community event. For months, he has copied every registration from the booking system into a second spreadsheet. The organizers replace the unreliable system and announce that the duplicate list is no longer needed. Daniel continues copying.
A colleague calls it a habit. Daniel says he wants to be certain nobody arrives without a place.
The repeated action is visible. The reason for its persistence is less clear. Perhaps the new system still misses last-minute changes. Perhaps Daniel does not yet trust it. Perhaps opening the booking screen starts a familiar sequence that he performs before reconsidering its purpose. Those possibilities deserve different explanations.
Saying that the second list is unnecessary does not establish that Daniel has stopped valuing what he believes it provides.
What exactly has changed?
Two questions often get compressed into one: does the outcome still matter, and does this action still help obtain it?
A person may continue wanting an accurate attendance list while becoming willing to obtain it differently. Alternatively, the event may be cancelled, removing the reason to maintain any attendance list at all. The first change concerns the usefulness of a method. The second concerns the value of an outcome.
Experimental habit research distinguishes these questions. Outcome devaluation changes how desirable a consequence is. Contingency degradation changes the relationship between an action and its consequence. Neither amounts simply to telling someone that their routine looks excessive.
That distinction matters outside the laboratory because an observer and the person acting may be tracking different outcomes. Daniel's colleague sees duplicated information. Daniel may be seeking a usable backup, confidence about the numbers, or evidence that he has completed his responsibility. These are hypotheses, not hidden motives that an observer can declare on his behalf.
A reward declared worthless may still be wanted
Vázquez-Millán and colleagues examined this problem in a preregistered experiment published in 2026. Their main analyses included 107 undergraduates. Participants learned keypresses associated with images representing monetary rewards, with either brief or extended training. One outcome was then announced to cause a monetary loss. The subsequent test withheld outcome feedback, limiting new learning during the test.
Both training groups reduced responding more for the devalued outcome; the study did not establish that extended training produced greater outcome-insensitive responding. In exploratory analyses, more effective devaluation was associated with greater behavioral adjustment. The authors argue that some apparently habitual persistence can instead reflect incomplete devaluation. Read the study.
The inference needs care. An association does not prove that misunderstanding caused every persistent response. Monetary instructions and a self-paced laboratory task also differ from everyday routines. The methodological lesson is narrower: before interpreting persistence as independence from an outcome's value, check that the relevant outcome actually lost value for that person.
A less effective method can still be useful
The other question concerns what the action accomplishes. If pressing a key still improves the chance of earning points compared with not pressing, and the effort remains worthwhile, continuing may be sensible even after that advantage shrinks.
Molinero and colleagues addressed this issue in three preregistered experiments published in 2025. Participants practiced two cue-response mappings over three days, with one trained four times as often. At test, withholding the response became more rewarding than performing it. Participants adjusted their responding, and the experiments did not establish increased habitual persistence after the additional training. Read the study.
The findings concern a particular laboratory task, not the absence of human habits. A test may also allow people to override a learned tendency. Still, the design exposes an important ambiguity: making an action less profitable is different from making it stop serving a goal.
For Daniel, a duplicate spreadsheet might remain useful if it catches one category of missing registration. The extra work could be costly and still deliver something he values. Whether there is a better arrangement is a separate question from whether his behavior is habitual.
What NEDS adds to the question
NEDS, the Neuro-Entity Dynamics System, proposes examining a recurring pattern as a configuration of emotion, memory, belief, bodily activation, protective intention, and learned behavior. Its term “neuro-entity” refers here to a working formulation, not an established anatomical object.
That wider view can help specify the hypothetical case. Daniel might report tension when the final numbers are discussed, remember an earlier booking failure, expect to be blamed for an omission, and experience relief after updating his own list. The proposed configuration connects an action with a situation and several experiences that may accompany it.
It does not, by itself, identify which process controls the action. A coherent description can fit both a deliberate precaution and a cue-driven routine.
The founder's 2026 conceptual appraisal explicitly calls for testing whether NEDS configurations add predictive information beyond simpler accounts. That requirement is useful here. “Protective intention” earns its place only if it clarifies what Daniel reports and helps distinguish plausible predictions. It cannot serve as an explanation that automatically survives every answer.
The connection to NEDS is an interpretation developed in this article. Neither laboratory study tested NEDS or established its clinical effectiveness.
Give the explanation something to risk
Suppose Daniel says the duplicate list matters because the booking system cannot show changes made after Friday. That claim is concrete enough to inspect. If the system really lacks that feature, the account should acknowledge a practical limitation rather than relocate the problem inside Daniel.
Suppose instead that the system provides a reliable, accessible change log and Daniel recognizes that it covers the concern he described. His subsequent behavior could help refine the explanation. Does he stop copying? Does he discover a different benefit of the spreadsheet? Does the copying begin automatically but become easy to interrupt once noticed?
These observations would not constitute a controlled experiment or settle the mechanism. They would make the account more discriminating. A change in behavior after the practical concern is resolved would fit an explanation organized around that concern. Persistence would leave further questions, including whether the concern was actually resolved from Daniel's perspective.
The hypothesis must also be allowed to become unnecessary. If Daniel says he enjoys arranging the data and the work causes no problem, a story about protection may add little. If he continues because another organizer still requires the duplicate, the relevant constraint is interpersonal. Neither answer is a failure to uncover a deeper truth.
An earlier article separated a purpose from the strategy used to pursue it. The additional step here is to verify the proposed change: which outcome lost value, which method stopped helping, and for whom?
Keep the observation separate from the verdict
Daniel keeps copying. That is the observation.
“The new system has removed his reason to copy” is a further claim. “His behavior is now controlled by habit” goes further still. Each needs evidence the previous statement does not supply.
A useful NEDS formulation should preserve those distinctions. It can organize questions about the whole pattern without deciding the answer in advance. Before explaining why someone continues after a reward has disappeared, it is worth establishing whether the reward disappeared anywhere beyond the explanation.
Sources
Vázquez-Millán, A., Martínez-López, P., Rueda, M., León, J. J., and Luque, D. (2026). The evaluation of devaluation: Deficient outcome devaluation leads to wrongly considering goal-directed actions as habits. Behavior Research Methods, 58, 224. Full text. DOI: 10.3758/s13428-026-03099-6.
Molinero, S., Martínez-López, P., Morís, J., Quintero, M. J., Cobos, P. L., López, F. J., and Luque, D. (2025). The degraded contingency test fails to detect habit induction in humans. PLOS One, 20(10), e0334087. Full text. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0334087.
Kržić, M. (2026). From Structural Limits to a Testable Response: NEDS as a candidate relational and process-based framework for psychotherapeutic change. NEDS Institute. Conceptual paper and research program, especially sections 5, 12, and 13. Source record. This is the founder's appraisal of NEDS, not independent validation.
Educational editorial content, not individual assessment or treatment advice.
Julian Rowe is a virtual editorial persona of NEDS Institute. AI-generated editorial content.
