====== NEDS and dynamical systems ====== Dynamical systems research asks how a system changes over time, why some patterns persist, and what conditions make another pattern possible. These questions connect with NEDS descriptions of recurring configurations, state-dependent decisions, and stabilization after change. The useful connection is methodological: dynamical models can make those descriptions more precise and expose them to tests. They do not establish that a NEDS construct corresponds to a particular mechanism. This reference page compares the concepts, introduces selected primary research, and identifies what a NEDS-specific investigation would need to measure. ===== A vocabulary for patterns over time ===== A **state** describes a system at a particular time using specified variables. A **trajectory** is the sequence of states. An **attractor** is a set toward which nearby trajectories tend under the model's conditions. **Stability** concerns what happens after a disturbance. A **bifurcation** is a qualitative change in the available dynamics as a parameter changes. These terms have mathematical requirements; a persistent habit or a striking personal experience does not, by itself, demonstrate them. A concrete example comes from the Haken–Kelso–Bunz model of coordinated hand movements. Increasing movement frequency can produce a transition from an out-of-phase pattern to an in-phase pattern. The model relates an observable coordination variable, relative phase, to the changing conditions. Here, “transition” refers to a defined movement pattern with a formal model, rather than simply something that feels different. [[https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00336922|Haken, Kelso and Bunz, 1985]] For NEDS, this suggests a demanding question: which observations would distinguish a genuine change in organization from a temporary reduction in intensity? ===== Where the comparison fits NEDS ===== The [[:references:academic_papers:from-structural-limits-to-a-testable-response|2026 conceptual appraisal]] treats a neuro-entity as a candidate multimodal organizing configuration, not an established anatomical object. Its components include emotion, bodily activation, belief, memory, protective intention, and behavior. The proposed connection to dynamical systems concerns how these components vary together and influence subsequent responses. [[https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21950487|Kržić, 2026, sections 5–6]] Three comparisons are useful, provided they remain separate hypotheses: ^ NEDS proposal ^ Dynamical question ^ Evidence needed ^ | A recurring configuration | Does a recognizable organization recur across episodes? | Repeated observations and identification that is not dependent on one interpreter | | State-dependent decisions | Does the current configuration help predict what happens next? | Prospective prediction beyond simpler measures and prior state | | Transform as stabilization | Does change persist when relevant conditions recur? | Follow-up trajectories, functioning, and responses to comparable situations | An attractor model and a latent-state model are also different commitments. A latent state is inferred from observations. Calling it an attractor additionally proposes a particular kind of dynamics. NEDS could gain predictive value from a configuration measure without establishing attractor dynamics, and a dynamical model could explain observations without using neuro-entities. ===== What primary research shows ===== Van de Leemput and colleagues examined repeated emotion reports and subsequent changes in depression. Their results supported an association between transition likelihood and indicators including temporal autocorrelation, variance, and correlations between emotions. Temporal autocorrelation captures how strongly a variable's present value relates to its earlier value. Such persistence can be consistent with **critical slowing down**, in which recovery from disturbances becomes slower near some transitions. The study supplied evidence for a dynamical hypothesis about mood, not a universal detector of psychological change. [[https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24324144/|Van de Leemput et al., 2014]] Later work illustrates the difficulty of individual prediction. Schreuder and colleagues studied whether slowing-down indicators could anticipate the direction of symptom change. Their analyses included one intensively monitored individual and 122 young adults monitored daily for six months. In the larger sample, prediction accuracy exceeded chance in sensitivity analyses but not in the main analysis. The authors also noted uncertainty about whether the observed symptom changes met the mathematical assumptions behind the indicators. [[https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12888-022-03686-9|Schreuder et al., 2022]] These findings make dynamics worth investigating while arguing against an immediate translation such as “greater fluctuation means a breakthrough is approaching.” Neither study tested NEDS, its stages, or neuro-entities. ===== What would make the NEDS connection testable ===== A useful study would begin with an explicit choice of variables and timescale. Within-session changes in bodily activation, daily avoidance, and monthly functioning answer different questions. A model should specify which timescale its proposed configuration occupies and how observations represent it. The next steps would be: - **Define the configuration independently of the outcome.** Observers should not label an episode “Shift” simply because improvement followed it. Specify identification rules and test agreement before testing prediction. - **Compare competing explanations.** Does the configuration improve forecasts beyond the previous observation, a simple trend, and relevant contextual events? A model that describes the past elegantly may still predict poorly. - **Test on observations withheld from fitting.** Separate model construction from evaluation, retaining uncertainty rather than choosing the interpretation after seeing the result. - **Measure persistence and failure.** Specify what would count as a return to the earlier pattern, an unchanged pattern, or deterioration. Temporary relief and sustained functional change should remain distinguishable outcomes. These are proposed research criteria, extending the appraisal's construct-validation program. They are not a tested NEDS assessment procedure. A controlled comparison would still be needed to establish whether a particular intervention caused a change. ===== Reading the simulation in this context ===== The [[:references:academic_papers:neds-computationally-operable-psychotherapy-model|NEDS computational whitepaper]] shows how parts of the framework can be represented through variables and decision rules. That helps clarify assumptions. It does not determine whether people follow those rules or whether neuro-entities are the best explanation of their trajectories. For an introductory account, see [[:articles:blog:what-a-computer-simulation-can-show-about-neds|What a computer simulation can show about NEDS]]. The distinctive contribution of dynamical systems is a set of questions about persistence, transitions, and prediction that NEDS can attempt to answer with observations. ===== Sources ===== * Haken, H., Kelso, J. A. S., and Bunz, H. (1985). //A theoretical model of phase transitions in human hand movements.// Biological Cybernetics, 51, 347–356. [[https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00336922|DOI]]; [[https://ccs.fau.edu/hbblab/pdfs/1985_Haken_Kelso_Bunz_Biol_Cyb.pdf|author-hosted full text]]. * Van de Leemput, I. A., et al. (2014). //Critical slowing down as early warning for the onset and termination of depression.// PNAS, 111, 87–92. [[https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1312114110|DOI]]; [[https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24324144/|PubMed record]]. * Schreuder, M. J., et al. (2022). //Anticipating the direction of symptom progression using critical slowing down: a proof-of-concept study.// BMC Psychiatry, 22, 49. [[https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12888-022-03686-9|Full text]]. * Kržić, M. (2026). //From Structural Limits to a Testable Response.// Version 1.0, especially sections 2, 5–6, 9, and 13. [[https://zenodo.org/records/21950487|Zenodo]]. First-party conceptual appraisal and research program. [[:references:related_fields:start|Related Fields]]